Trends are created by fundamental data and not by charts.
In this article we would like to introduce you to our COT-Strategy. This is one of our major strategies that allowed us to increase our trading capital from $ 14.000 to over $ 430.000 within just 5 years. In 2017 we participated in World Cup Championship of Futures Trading® and won the 3rd place by achieving a 111% profit.
We believe, the market trends arise from the fundamental market changes and not from the changes on the chart. Accordingly, we build our strategy based on the COT data that originates from the weekly Commitment of Traders Report. It includes the up-to-date positions of reportable marker players. The goal of the Commitment of Traders Report is to provide transparency in regard to open and outstanding options and future contracts on the market. The data is published each Friday after the close of trading session. In this way, all other market players can understand the positioning of the big trader groups (commercials, large traders and small traders).
We took advantage of this information and evaluated the behavior of these three groups using the COT reports from 1983 to 2013. The analysis showed us how the big players position themselves before rally. This information is the foundation of our trading strategy. We call it COT-signal. Every Sunday we analyse 30 futures markets for such signals.
Figure 1 shows COT-signals for the sugar market. Red arrows show signals for going short (short signal) and green ones for going long (long signal). As you can see on this figure, the COT-signals are very reliable, especially if they match the weekly trend.
Once a COT-signal is present, we proceed as follows:
Step 1 of 8: Weekly Trend.
After getting a COT-signal, we first verify the weekly trend. As already mentioned, signals are more reliable if they match the trend direction.
Step 2: Commercials and Open Interest.
Step 2 of 8: Commercials and Open Interest.
In addition to step one, we take a closer look at the “open interest” and the “commercials” (Figure 2).
Step 3: Sentiment.
COT-signal can be verified by the sentiment that represent the the mood of the public (Figure 3).
We use software called “Trade Navigator” that indicates two sentiments, the fast and the slow one.
Ideally, both sentiments are in the same positive or negative zone.
Step 4: Seasonal Trend.
This is how an ideal COT-signal looks like
(Figure 5). Of course, not every signal is so perfect. However, in order to use a COT-signal, it is sufficient to verify it by just two out of three checks (steps) mentioned above.
It is important to mention that the validity of a COT-signal lasts for approximately 6 weeks. The historical data evaluation confirms that.
Step 5: Timing.
In order to identify the right time for market entry, we analyse the trend of the daily chart. Its highs and lows, as well as the divergence may indicate an upcoming trend change. The divergence can be identified by the RSI indicator. This indicator is regularly a part of almost each standard software.
On the Figure 6 we see that the price reached the new lows even before the COT-signal occurred. However, the RSI indicator did not follow the price and thus, created a price divergence (blue lines). That’s a good indication of an upcoming trend change.
Step 6: Market Entry and Exit.
We start looking for an optimal entry as soon as there are divergences or trend structures that indicate upcoming trend changes. We may use different entry techniques. An effective and simple one is the entry with the trend (see Figure 7). On 24/03/2018 we received a COT-signal. In addition, we identified a divergence between the price and the RSI indicator on the daily chart (see Figure 6).
The price reached a higher high and a highes low. Accordingly, the trend was confirmed by the price breaking the higher high. Simultaneously it identified our point of entry. We placed our stop loss below the low of 2 previous bars. The target was defined as movement between medium term high and low (horizontal blue line in the chart). Based on this analysis and defined strategy, we were able to reach the target and to earn $ 2,500 in profits by risk of $ 500.
We would like to highlight the importance of following scenario: if the price breaks through the lower low (see Figure 7), meaning if the secondary trend continues to sustain, we consider the set up as invalid and wait until the trend changes again. This procedure may sound complicated, but it is very easy to implement. We have a weekly trend (main trend) and a daily trend (secondary trend).
The secondary trend is the correction of the main trend. As soon as the secondary trend turns towards the main trend, we start looking for an entry. If the secondary trend continue to sustain, we do nothing and wait for the next opportunity.
As soon as the entry, exit and risk per trade are defined, we move on to the next step.
Step 7: Risk- and Position-Management
This is one of the most important points that may lead to a success or failure in trading. First, we define the maximum risk per trade. It essentially depends on the risk type of the trader. Generally the total risk should be between 2 and 5% of the investment. We, for example, trade our pro-account with 2% risk per trade. Next, we determine the risk per contract (stop loss). Based on this input, we calculate the size of our positions.
For example, our trading capital amounts $ 200,000 and we are going to take a risk of 2% or $ 4,000 per trade. From the example above, our risk per contract (stop loss) is $ 500. Accordingly, we will trade $ 4,000 / $ 500 = 8 sugar contracts.
The risk money management (RMM) formula can be defined as follows:
(trading capital) x (max risk per trade) / (stop loss) = (position size)
Step 8: Correlation.
If your trading capital has reached a certain size that allows you to trade several markets simultaneously, the correlation between the markets should be taken into account. Ideally, the portfolio should be well diversified. Further information about the correlation of different the markets can be found on the website of the Moore Research Center www.mrci.com or it can be defined by own analysis.
Summing Up, our setup looks as follows:
2. Weekly trend analysis
3. COT-signal confirmations by
• Open interest
• Seasonal trend
• Daily trend analysis
5. Risk and position management
6. Correlation between several setups
According to our experience, you will require an account of at least $ 15,000 (better $ 30,000) in order to trade based on the COT-strategy. The disadvantage of a smaller account of $ 15,000 is that you can not trade each market set up. Otherwise your risk may be too high or you have to choose just one of many markets. With the bigger account of $ 30,000 you can trade 2 to 3 markets and achieve certain results much faster. However, we had $ 14,000 back then only. We tested the strategy with the historical data and gained a clear understanding about the possible drawdowns, losing trades etc. That gave us the required confidence for our small trading account.
Another advantage of this strategy is the low effort for it’s preparation and implementation. Fridays we receive the COT data. On the weekend we analyse the markets, identify the COT-signals and choose the best set ups. Depending on your experience, it may require 1 to 3 hours. Sundays we define our entry and exit points. During the week, we only have to place the orders and adjust it if required. This takes you about 5 to 15 minutes daily. It is possible that all your trades will be completed until Tuesday, meaning no extra work until the beginning of the next cycle. Thus, this strategy ideally suits for part-time traders and full time employees.
We prefer this strategy because it meets all the criteria of a good strategy – it is fundamental, comprehensible, time-saving, suitable for small accounts and it is easy to implement.
We offer the chance to follow the COT strategy in a real money trade and to learn from it. If you are interested and would like to find out more, feel free to contact us by clicking here.
Strategy name: COT strategy
Account min size: $ 15,000
Markets: commodity and currency futures
Time unit: weekly and daily charts
Time required: 2-3 hours per week
Suitable for part-time traders: Yes